352 Comments
User's avatar
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

do not watch this woman being burnt alive if you cannot, please do not. but this is what happened and no police, no passerby, no person on the train, did anything, she stood there no doubt in shock, dying, in pain and no one did anything, just walked by and bitched.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I am having a difficult time believing this happened as it did

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

is it New York people are dehumanized? I mean this makes no sense to walk on by?

Expand full comment
Margaret Shattuck's avatar

It's not just New Yorkers. It's all over this country. How many times have we seen girls getting beaten up in schools, and the other kids just standing around and taking videos with their phones instead of trying to help the girl. It's widespread. Too many people have lost their frigging minds. There is just no morality any more. Our world has turned completely dark.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you for saying this for it is 100% true

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

I agree 100%. Influencers on social media, nonstop selfies, tictoc, snapchat and whatever else. People & their children, have become zombies, slaves to technology. Much to the delight of the CCP. Parents are not taking charge of their children's use of electronic devices. Will this be a wake up call? I highly doubt it. This is a dehumanizing process. New York City and San Francisco are ground zero.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I hope its the wake up call, no matter once you saw it, it destroys the soul...

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Dennis Rader aka BTK (Bind Torture Kill) iwas a devoted volunteer at Christ Lutheran Church where he was active on the church council and shortly befoe his arrest he had ascended to the board’s presidency. He practically lived at the churc. Like many serial killers, including Ted Bundy, Rader was a staunch Republican. He was from Wichita.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

hhhmmm

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

Ted Bundy was deadly because not only was he evil, he was smart too...a wicked combination to be both

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Bundy was a classic RINO, similar to the Pence, Kinzinger, Cheney Republicans of today. He was a necrophile and psychopath. He worked for the Republican Governor of WA and was a delegate to the Republican National Convention. Bundy has gone into not just the national consciousness but the world consciousness. If you talk to foreigners about Bundy, some see him as almost the archetypical American, a neocon, i.e., extremely wicked, shockingly evil and vile. Bundy's victims were the opposite. He preyed on kind-hearted women and girls, typically faking an injury to lure a victim. He kept a stash of casts and crutches in his home and would often don one and then go and ask an attractive young female for help carrying something to his car. Serial killers have asked children to help them find a lost puppy or kitten

Expand full comment
HorizonD7's avatar

It is not a coincidence that this unfortunate woman received no help soon after the ridiculous Daniel Penny show trial. Reluctant, even cowardly, male behavior is the goal of the Left, and they have largely succeeded.

If the government, society and media made an "about face" and began applauding self-defense and Good Samaritan bravery, outrageous acts like this would immediately start to diminish.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

very important actually true statement "Reluctant, even cowardly, male behavior is the goal of the Left, and they have largely succeeded."

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

This is what I have been worried about for the past 40 years when I first started to notice feminism I knew it would come to this. All these years of trying to warn people was a futile endeavor.

When I would see women acting more masculine in the movies people didn’t wanna listen. When they started shamming men on any TV program or commercial on TV nobody would listen. They wouldn’t even believe it was happening.

When is this going to end? ?!?!

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

I disagree, personally, about the reference to the Daniel Penny case.

This Penny case has nothing directly to do with this case. In this girl case the damage/crime already happened and no one helped HER. Also there is an online Good Samartian Law in NYC.

Expand full comment
Terta's avatar

Pretzle logic + mental gymnastics = BS

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

Can you elaborate pls?

Expand full comment
Terta's avatar

If the abundance of people (few or many ?) had intervened rather than purposefully oblivious the victim might have been saved if not spared this horrific death.

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

I dont understand your position sorry. They should have helped, no?

How do you know that they couldnt have helped and spare the death?

What has this to do with "Pretzle logic + mental gymnastics = BS"?

The Daniel Penny case is a completely different case. I disagree with the case result btw.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

It's disgraceful that nobody tried to help. It's small consolation but at least New Yorkers are probably feeling sad over what happened rather than opening champagne bottles and dancing in the streets like they would If the victim had been a Big Pharma boss or health insurance CEO.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you for saying this for it is true.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

issue is it shows us the social contract between us as human beings no longer exists...COVID broke it, dont you think or helped break it.

Expand full comment
Clive Bragdon's avatar

That's it Dr A!! You are so right that Covid was the straw that finally broke the back of the America I grew up in and I am so sick to my stomach when I think about what was done to this beautiful young lady. Just sick!

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

I remember when someone started choking at Howard Johnson’s I ran right over there. I would’ve at least started rolling her on the ground. For God sake, I can’t believe this.

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

And I’m not saying I’m better than anyone else. I’m saying that that would be a normal reaction to help someone. People are sick now.

Expand full comment
Mr. Raven's avatar

Meh that health company CEO killed more people through denying health claims than any serial killer, no sympathy at all. That's VERY different than burning an innocent young woman to death.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

lots here Mr. Raven is 100% correct. I dont condone killing, I dont. but there is lots to unpack here. her death I think will reshape USA...I hope

Expand full comment
Seismic7's avatar

Hang Kathy hochul and the luciferian leftwingnut vile Jews she serves*

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

I hope so. England and Ireland started rising up after certain things happened there, but they don’t have arms to defend themselves. We do.

Expand full comment
Seismic7's avatar

Time flies..treachery..perfidy..sudden death everywhere... underneath the city...now is..mortal peril..as the black crow flies...God speed Mr Raven**Let all decent folk REARM NOW**

Expand full comment
Hunterson7's avatar

Mr. Raven,

The CEO killed not one person. Stop conflating.

Expand full comment
Mr. Raven's avatar

Yes they did denying treatment to chronically ill people will lead to their preventable death. Now go worship your pile of worthless fiat JewBucks subhuman.

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

As I mentioned in another post NYC is a dead city. My heart is completely broken to see this level of evil. The subhuman scum that did this deserves the fate he delivered to Amelia. I believe humanity overall is good. But there are actual demons walking among us and they are absolute cowards. The only way to stop this evil is to deliver it back to them. Publicly. Swiftly.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you for this, this is for her parents, to know people like you exist who see the depravity...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

In all my life, I have not seen anything like this. and the trouble is that no one helped...no one...no police, no one, there is no excuse here.

Expand full comment
Jp's avatar

To watch a police officer in the video walk right by is SHOCKING!!!!! He should be FIRED immediately! What happened to serve & PROTECT?

Expand full comment
Annette's avatar

What happened to being “human”?

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

None. The normal thing is to help people. Especially in an emergency.

Expand full comment
Annie's avatar

People have been systematically desensitized. So much violence in movies and tv. Violence all day long & night in large cities. Sadly, people are turning into dimwitted drones…

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

not sure if my prior cued stacked Merry Christmas piece should go out at 830 as planned...I am in two minds. this has broken it all.

Expand full comment
Ronda's avatar

Always celebrate merry Christmas, that doesn’t take away from the life of Amelia, she is with the source our father now she’s not in pain.

And I totally am old testament. I agree on earth we need to give back to evil humans, putting out an equal and opposite force it’s physics, to stop them.

As a woman, I do hold the men of America responsible for this, men are supposed to protect women and children and the vulnerable, and they are very passive as a group. They have lost their instincts and their nature. I personally would’ve done anything to stop this. I would’ve got whatever I needed to clothing blankets my own clothing jackets. I don’t know if there’s fire extinguishers present. I’ve never been on the subway, but I would’ve screamed at people and snapped them out of it till they helped.

I am Generation X and I’m 100% sure that Cellular phones and the Internet are responsible for the brainwash along with the Gwen towers disguised as the 5G towers. I was a computer scientist and programmer in my 20s, and I left it behind because it disappeared time, and made me antisocial, and desensitized me. All that radiation isn’t good for the human being.

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

We cannot only blame men when so many women were fooled by feminism immediately!

But yes, when the government demanded women started leaving their precious babies with strangers after only weeks old, they should have had the balls to fight this.

That’s when everything was lost .

In the 80s

When women put their babies in the daycare, not to feed them, but to descend to “ whoever dies with the most toys wins” which is exactly what every bumper sticker in the 80s said

Not feed your kids, die with the most toys. People started buying huge homes and now we have master suites and everything else a full garage a full double garage. And millions of items that will never be used in tons and tons of storage that we have in this America that we never had even in 1968 when theRE were NONE

ALL THESE USELESS ITEMS IN STORAGE CONTAINERS AROUND AMERICA ARE THE REASON WOMEN ARE WORKING LONG HOURS AND hurting their children

Expand full comment
Ronda's avatar

Well, I didn’t blame men.I just pointed out of fact.. I can’t speak to that because I raised my own children and homeschooled them. I don’t click all that stuff, I collect experiences. There’s always an angry woman out there to bash other women. I grew up in the 80s, you really don’t know if those women, if their husbands were taking good enough care of them. Men are the leaders of the family. My mother was able to stay home because her husband worked hard and didn’t complain much.

I thought though, that we were mostly talking about protecting people, strangers even, in civil society, aka being a man.

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

Yes, I totally agree with you. The men should not have allowed it, but unfortunately, a lot of women did their part by competing with other women and wanting more material possessions. I would’ve never married anybody who didn’t feel the same way about me staying home.

Expand full comment
My Friend Lisa's avatar

Yes yes yes.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I agree, publicly and swiftly and they must pain...suffer them

Expand full comment
OpenVoiceFreedom's avatar

An eye for an eye case if there ever was one, which there are many since the border was opened.

Expand full comment
Michael M. Jones's avatar

Manhattan is focus of evil but Brooklyn,Long Island and Staten Island lean republican especially so LI and SI..Let's not discount all of NY. I also believe upstate is good.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Americans will help if they think there could be a danger to themselves if they don't help. They care about themselves but not so much about women being raped and/or murdered in proximity to them. This has been extensively studied. In this case the witnesses would have considered the fire unlikely to spread and potentially harm them personally. Therefore they would not have been motivated to help

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

so very disturbing

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

really is a testimony on humanity now

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

was she holding on for us, for someone to help her...holding on to the railing

Expand full comment
KarlM Alias's avatar

By that time, it was likely too late. Many serious burn victims say they wish they had died, so it is perhaps a mercy that she did not live.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

And yet some recover, albeit with lasting difficulties and trauma. It's dreadful that not only did she suffer but that her life was taken from her.

Expand full comment
Margaret Shattuck's avatar

All they would have needed was a very large coat, or a large blanket, etc., to try to get to that woman and get her out. She needed to be immediately removed, wrapped up, and rolled on the ground to put out the fire, but unfortunately, most of our people these days are too stupid to even know that.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

we are filled to the brim in anguish...

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

You are so right. I don't understand why no one would help. Daniel Penny God bless him for preventing this type of violence.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you Chelie, what is ravaging is she was moving as if she was confused, holding on for us to help her

Expand full comment
Pnoldguy's avatar

And look where it got Daniel. In court, fighting to stay out of jail. That's why no one in NY stepped in to help. In 2024 good samaritans get arrested.

Expand full comment
St. Alia the Knife's avatar

Alvin Bragg needs to be sued for malicious prosecution. Oh, and obviously fired and disbarred. Jail would be appropriate but seems very unlikely.

Expand full comment
OpenVoiceFreedom's avatar

That went through my mind when I saw the video. And what was waving a jacket or something going to do when all it would have done was fan the flames?

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

The danger is the LAW. They dont even have to know the law. Rape/murder is another topic because you could assume that the perpetrator or gang has a weapon or they could rape/murder you too. This was a local fire I assume. Very local, except for fast igniting clothes, this is to be seen what the person wore. I cant even imagine how someone can be ignited/immolated, because your clothing usually shouldnt ignite so easily with just you holding your match or lighter at it.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

you must have fire extinguishers every so much space in that car, the police could have acted...this defies logic.

Expand full comment
Annie's avatar

She was wearing nylon stockings…

Expand full comment
What's avatar

Sucks. That's the conclusion and worse is to come. This is what "liberation" looks like; getting orally raped to death by an immigrant while sleeping or getting lit on fire while sleeping. Choose, white woman.

Expand full comment
Mark Schirmer's avatar

Say someone actually did something. They could be Daniel Pennyied.

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

They did it with a rape and murder all those years ago. It took hours and people were happily listening.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

The woman who was burned was not a CEO and most likely had not ripped anybody off. so with regard to the prosecution of the perp there will be only a fraction of the energy expended on that compared to what's going into prosecuting Luigi Mangione

Expand full comment
Effra's avatar

That’s because it was a psyop, intended to inflame all Americans. The “victim” was most likely a crisis actor / stunt man: look at the calves and thighs on the “burning woman.”

Has everyone forgotten about the Smith-Mundt Modernization Act of 2012?

Expand full comment
Norman Gilmore's avatar

Yes it’s possibly all to do with Dividing Controlling and Conquering the US Public .

Expand full comment
Woke PIG Killer's avatar

Because you’re ignorant

Expand full comment
Mary's avatar

But if a Daniel Penny stepped in the New York ‘law’ would put him on trial - evil lives here!

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

yes

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

that no one helped?

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Remember the Uvalde school shooting, how the police cowered in the hallway and let the kids get murdered. Those Uvalde police were far braver and more compassionate than the average American.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I wrote that the Uvalde police were near scum, to allow the children to die.

Expand full comment
Diane Eddington's avatar

Cowards just collecting taxpayer dollars. DEI comes to mind... Also, in my opinion, men today are not the same as they once were defined. Normandy comes to mind... I am NOT knocking all men, because there are real men out there.

Expand full comment
Pnoldguy's avatar

How compassionate would you be while using hand sanitizer at the end of the hall while children were actively being murdered? If you think that is compassion I don't want to ever be around you.

Iirc, a sheriff rushed past them and subdued the shooter at much risk to his life.

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

"Criminally Negligent Homicide occurs when someone causes the death of another person through actions that they failed to perceive as having a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death (NYPL 15.05 and 125.10). This is a class E felony."

(https://www.joeyjacksonlaw.com/criminal-defense/murder-and-manslaughter-charges/homicide/)

Under New York Penal Law § 125.10, you could be prosecuted for criminally negligent homicide if with criminal negligence you kill another person. According to New York Penal Law § 15.05(4), acting with "criminal negligence" means that you failed to perceive a substantial risk that your actions or INACTION would result in another person's death. The risk must constitute a gross deviation from the standard of care that a reasonable person would observe under the circumstances.

(https://criminaldefense.1800nynylaw.com/new-york-penal-law-125-10-criminally-negligent-homicide.html)

"Negligence is an action or omission that is inconsistent with the course of action a prudent individual would take given the circumstances. Individuals whose negligent conduct results in injuries to others are liable for the damages."

(https://www.samndan.com/resources/new-york-negligence-laws/)

https://www.nycourts.gov/judges/cji/2-PenalLaw/125/125-10.pdf

The bystanders can be charged. If guilty according to the requirements must be proven, but this is the least the state/city can do. There was no gun or other immediate life-threating threats involved. I assume the fire was initially local on her clothing, even at a later stage you could have easily used your jacked to eliminate the oxygen input and with it estinguish the fire. I saw the perpetrator was intoxicated, I dont think all the bystanders were as well, even though it seem so...

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

Eh.. this looks very surreal. She doesnt even move, how is that possible. Is it some body reaction to being burned alive? I dont think so?

IMO the surronding people especially the police man should be 100% charged with failure to render aid resulting in death. This is just insanity. The soon you see someone on fire you must immediately help, like in miliseconds. I dont know anyone who wouldnt do that.

In mass events there is this "bystander effect" but that no one helps in this case is just insanity. What the fuck is wrong with people in NYC?

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

it is shocking

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Remember the case of Justine Damond in Minneapolis? After she called 9-1-1 to report the possible assault of a woman in an alley behind her house the cops showed up and shot her dead.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

yes, the beast islamic police officer, I wrote about this, he identified as shariah islam and that she dared come out of her home in her nightgown...the beast shot her dead just like that...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

Mohamed Noor, the former Minneapolis police officer convicted in the fatal shooting of an Australian woman who called 911 for help, was sentenced Friday to 12 1/2 years in prison.

Noor, 33, fatally shot Justine Ruszczyk Damond, on July 15, 2017, after Noor and his partner responded to Damond’s call to report that she thought a woman was being sexually assaulted.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

the they tossed the murder conviction when we know it was murder

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

Ex-Minneapolis cop Mohamed Noor gets lighter prison sentence after murder conviction tossed

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

A former Minneapolis police officer who fatally shot an unarmed woman who called 911 to report a possible crime was re-sentenced to nearly five years in prison Thursday after the state’s highest court overturned his murder conviction last month.

Mohamed Noor was initially sentenced to 12.5 years in the 2017 fatal shooting of Justine Ruszczyk Damond, a 40-year-old bride-to-be who was concerned about a possible rape in progress behind her home.

Expand full comment
Diane Eddington's avatar

Is Joe Biden going to pardon this tool of Satan?

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I though same, maybe the pain immobilizes you? I dont know. I am numbed.

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

I can only imagine maybe at some later stages, but no one helped in the early stage .. Another thing is modern (often synthetic) clothes which have a very low ignition point, dangerous if someone want to ignite you. I dont know the whole details of this event, but surely the surrounding people could have helped here (in any form)

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

you raised a key point as to clothing

Expand full comment
Laggy's avatar

How are you a doctor and don’t know about the sociological tenets of bystander apathy?

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

as an academic scientist I know everything on bystander effect...the purpose of stacks and this type of forum is for us ALL, not just I to have an opinion and share so that we learn...I dont use here to preach and teach you...if I took you down my areas of expertise you wont understand me. and same you...so respect me and that

Expand full comment
Laggy's avatar

You have 50x responses of shock and dismay. You’re literally spamming “Humans dropped the ball”. We get it. Why? What’s your angle? Why do you keep fucking repeating yourself?

Expand full comment
Margaret Shattuck's avatar

I'm sure she was overcome with both shock and fear. It can paralyze a person, which I suspect is what happened to her.

But yes, that reality that NO ONE tried to help her is just hard to swallow. Humanity is gone.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I think, I know she was shocked and immobilized but waiting for someone...

we failed. we had a chance to ensure we did not leave her behind and we did.

Expand full comment
Adriana's avatar

Justice is gone. If that would work as it should people would not hesitate to help. Look what is happening in Germany if you talk against or do something against an illegal migrant.

Expand full comment
Diane Eddington's avatar

I have an opinion that the Lord takes you the second you feel pain.

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

I agree with you but the blue district voters decide the elections there. We have family in upstate NY and it’s sad what’s happened to the state.

Expand full comment
Primum non nocere's avatar

I will NOT go into details as to why it happens on this post but, yes, I am not surprised she remained standing. Horriffic.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

where is it gone? the humanity?

Expand full comment
Diane Eddington's avatar

Off the face of the earth, it appears. Sadly.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

if you can, please explain, we want to know...it is so shocking

Expand full comment
Primum non nocere's avatar

Its called burned induced "pugilistic attitude". Its graphic.

Here is a reference paper on the subject. Its a rough article to read if youre not prepared. Apologies in advance...

https://emedicine.medscape.com/article/1975728-overview#a1

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you so it is that the person has no control...of this

Expand full comment
Primum non nocere's avatar

correct... no control

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

Yes, that makes it more horrible but thank you for the information. I like to know the facts.

Expand full comment
Bulwark's avatar

I agree that the event is layered, first the crime in itself to immolate someone, and the other second part is that no one helped.

Expand full comment
Grand Mal Twerkin's avatar

Have you seen video of self-immolations? There have been some recent examples, and they look just like this, with the victim not moving at all, or not moving much, whether sitting or standing. It may have something to do with paralysis by fear, or pain receptors in the skin being burned and damaged. I think when burning victims do run or flail, it’s because they started moving before the fire got intense enough to prevent movement

Expand full comment
Hunterson7's avatar

George Soros and his democrat party is what is the matter. Soros and the WEF, and the party they control, did this to us.

Expand full comment
Grumpy Steve's avatar

Our part in it is that we've allowed it.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

It could be cultural that you don't know anyone who wouldn't help, if you grew up in Germany.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

you mean Germans would not? I dont know hence asking.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

No, I think Germans would help

Expand full comment
Grumpy Steve's avatar

I don't think this is cultural and specific to Americans. I think it's indicative of the desensitization of those living and dealing with the insanity that's been visited upon blue cities. Police deal with so much bullshit they become numb to the horror. It's a defence mechanism.

Expand full comment
Diane Eddington's avatar

My son is 23 and when attending elementary school, possibly first grade, the children were taught what to do if faced with fire... Drop, tuck and roll among other things. The police officer should be held accountable for his in actions.

Expand full comment
Jp's avatar

My thoughts exactly!

Expand full comment
Kathleen Taylor's avatar

I could not watch.

But I would think it could have been possible immediately to move the girl to the floor and roll her over and over, back and forth, until the flame was extinguished. Isn't that the advice given if we discover own own clothing in flames?

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

good you did not wactch

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

it was a failure on humanity, our society as a whole

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I pray the Lord receives her with open arms

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

Amen.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

On March 13th, 1964, in New York City, Kitty Genovese was arriving home from work in the middle of the night when she was brutally stabbed to death by disgusting criminal Winston Moseley, an African American psychopath and necrophile. He said later that his motive for the attack was simply "to kill a woman", saying he preferred to kill women because "they were easier and didn't fight back".Two weeks after the murder, The New York Times published an article claiming that thirty-eight witnesses saw or heard the attack, including the woman screaming for help, and that none of them called the police or came to her aid. When Moseley was apprehended, and Chief of Detectives Albert Seedman asked him how he dared to attack a woman in front of so many witnesses, the psychopath calmly replied, 'I knew they wouldn't do anything, people never do.' The incident prompted inquiries into what became known as the bystander effect, or "Genovese syndrome." It was later found that there were fewer witnesses than stated and some did try to help. However, most did not. It was subsequently reportedly found in several studies that Americans are more likely to come to the aid of a woman in their neighborhood yelling "fire" than to a woman yelling "rape." In the case of the sound of a woman yelling "fire," Americans become concerned that the fire could spread and harm them or their property. In the case of a woman yelling "rape" they care less and don't want to get involved because it could be a hassle.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

very disturbing...Wthan Moseley was apprehended, and Chief of Detectives Albert Seedman asked him how he dared to attack a woman in front of so many witnesses, the psychopath calmly replied, 'I knew they wouldn't do anything, people never do.' The incident prompted inquiries into what became known as the bystander effect, or "Genovese syndrome. It was later found that there were fewer witnesses than stated and some did try to help.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

this situation broke me. I admit

Expand full comment
Diane Eddington's avatar

It's all horrific.

Expand full comment
St. Alia the Knife's avatar

One of the things we were taught in driver's ed is to consider scenarios and decide on proper reactions ahead of time. This not only shortens the reaction time if an incident occurs but increases the likelihood of action. Most people, understandably, don't ponder to themselves, "what would I do if I saw a person on fire in a subway car?" In this instance there may have also been a variant of the "white coat effect" as there is a police officer (from the stills I have seen, I do not wish to view the video) present so it is easy to assume he's in charge. As with most of the posters here I envision I would jump in to help but I, thankfully, have not been in this situation, so I cannot be sure. I am filled with sadness and anger that this was done.

Expand full comment
Jen Spencer's avatar

I can't even imagine how her family must feel..her parents especially!

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you...I know you are overcome too.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

It could be that in growing up the islands you were exposed to people who had a sense of community and who cared about people other than themselves. You grew up to be altruistic and compassionate. So you are aghast and stunned by the unfathomable cruelty of what the vile criminal did and by the callous actions of those who did nothing to help. I too am aghast. In fact the whole world is aghast. This incident made international headlines.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you with these words...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I feel so ashamed to her parents...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

it is a social unwritten contract between you and I that if I run into danger while out, someone will help me...or my child or loved one...this one incident tells us NOT so...

Expand full comment
David Rinker's avatar

It is agape love, love of neighbor. Jesus said the second greatest commandment after love of God, is "love your neighbor as yourself." Jesus gave the parable of the good Samaritan as an example for us. The Samaritan assisted a total stranger at his own expense. Jesus indicated that love of neighbor begins with love of ourself. Perhaps this is an indication of the self-loathing felt by many people. Negative self-image is projected onto others. I always say, "If you're a piece of shit, all you can do is shit on everyone else. There is a psychological explanation for all behaviors. I hold a PSYCH degree.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you David, it is as if we need to learn here and form this, we as a society must heal from this, if we ever can. I dont know

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Heroism is not, as Americans are taught, surrendering to the enemy because your plane was shot down, then working for the Viet Cong while you're in a POW camp, before later becoming a zsenator and running for President. It's not butchering civilians in a drone strike while seated at a terminal thousands of miles away, because you were only following orders.

Philip Zimbardo, of Stanford Prison Experiment fame, said in a TED talk on the subject of evil:

"To be a hero, you have to learn to be a deviant, because you're always going against the conformity of the group. Heroes are ordinary people whose social actions are extraordinary. Those people who act. The key to heroism is two things: A. you have to act when other people are passive. B. you have to act socio-centrically, not egocentrically."

In the Darley-Batson study (1973), which was inspired by the Bible’s tale involving a Samaritan woman who helped Jesus, Darley and Batson met with a group of American seminarians, individually, and asked each one to prepare a short, extemporaneous talk on a given biblical theme, then walk over to a nearby building to present it. Along the way to the presentation, each student ran into a man slumped in an alley, head down, eyes closed, coughing and groaning. The question was, who would stop and help?

"The authors state: “Indeed, on several occasions, a seminary student going to give his talk on the parable of the Good Samaritan literally stepped over the victim as he hurried on this way.”

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

this is very informative

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

How do you get people to see the inhumanity in bystanders looking then walking away and not doing anything. At the point we are at they need to be shamed. And the Police? Fire them and charge them with dereliction of duty.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I am moved to say yes, they are culpable...we had to help...had to

Expand full comment
Chelie's avatar

Good Samaritan Laws protect civilians who help people who are in danger. The law protects people from being sued, to encourage civilians to help when someone is in danger or distress.

Maybe NYC needs to post signs in public areas to make people aware.

Expand full comment
Victoria Jean Bingham's avatar

That's even more shocking than the crime. How can you WATCH and do NOTHING?? In my 14 years in NYC, (I drove a taxi for 2 of them) I came to people's rescue many times -on the street (saved a man's life in the blizzard of April 6th 1982,. on the subway in Brooklyn (Stopped a mugging), and on 6th avenue at 58th st. stopped a robbery.. There's more, but how hard is it - in winter no less - to take off your damn jacket and wrap the woman in it? Who doesn't know that? Are we already living in a world of zombies?

Expand full comment
Laggy's avatar

Simple case of bystander apathy. It is inherent in massive cosmopolitan cities. Everyone thought surely everyone else would do something. This is the poison of urbanization.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

for Amelia, the border must be closed. in fact we must name it Amelia's law. Close it. and mass deport. for her, in her memory, what happened is so monstrous it matches deporting 30 million people. all. and still is not enough. for what was done to her and if Trump fails to close the border and mass deport as he promised and I dont mean only illegals who commit crimes, then am out.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I will reserve judgment until 47 is sworn in but on the mRNA vaccines to be stopped instantly on swearing in and closure of border...he can keep all other actions to help fix USA. just these 2 actions

Expand full comment
John P. Wallis's avatar

We must not only close our borders and deal with the 30,000,000 illegals already here. The motherfuckers who permitted the open border policies must be collected, tried, convicted and executed for their Crimes Agaonst Everyday Americans. Fuck them. No mercy. All of the piece of shit representatives who voted in favor of and continue to support FREE TRADE policies that continue killing Americans nationwide daily must also be collected, charged, tried, prosecuted and promptly EXECUTED. This is The USA. Start acting like Americans instead of pussies. Everything that has played out over the past 30 years in The USA is directly attributable to the TRAITORS who brought US So called FREE TRADE. There is nothing Free about it. #DefundTyranny #DepopulateTheDepopulators #FreedomIsNotFree

Expand full comment
Creole Gumbo's avatar

Info released minutes ago identified the woman as a 61 year old New Jersey woman Debrina Kawam. If you look at the photo it is far more consistent with a 61 year old in poor physical condition and not the young Amelia.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

Drew Skonberg,DC

Dr. Drew’s Newsletter

4m

I have no words. This ranks up there with the picture of the Vietnamese burnt young girl that turned public opinion against the war.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Oh, I just posted on that and now I find that it's already acknowledged. Yes, this is a very good point!

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

there is too much sorrow here

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

what happened here

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

she was holding onto the railing in the subway car, I think hoping someone would come to help her...and no one came...we left her...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I am so sorry what was done to her...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

and we failed her...

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

no one helped her

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

would you have helped her?

Expand full comment
Ronda's avatar

Absolutely

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

so many things I wanted to share and talk about but could not, I had to share this.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

this may be a watershed moment for America...to claw back its soul from the abyss that is now circling the drain

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

we as people, in NYC, in USA, failed in so many ways, I think this will scar America for many years. it is really a commentary on human life now.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

the social contract, is now broken.

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

But are people paying attention? I don’t see people in the streets like I did in England and Ireland. I see people going back to work like nothing happened.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

this video can destroy your soul, so dont watch

Expand full comment
Primum non nocere's avatar

Unfortunately you must compartmentalize these events in your mind lest you risk losing your soul. Not to be forgotten. Rather, a moment in time that forever hardens your resolve to live on and never accept such things as NOTHING but true evil.

Someone told me this once after a really bad case of unhumanity I witnessed...it helped then and may help you now..

"Nothing can change what happened. Your pity or anger is neither necessary or helpful. It will serve only to cloud your mind. Only through clarity of mind will justice be brought forth for the deceased. Do not fail them."

That is our charge for her.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you...I know you all feel as devastated as me and we are not her family.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I just dont get how no one helped her

Expand full comment
Ronda's avatar

Yes!!

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

I haven't watched. Not sure if I will. Probably not. It is bad enough, even though the photo was taken years ago, seeing the image of Napalm Girl, the defining image for its era of America, depicting a distraught little girl in the road with clothes burned off after being napalm bombed by America.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

dont watch it, it destroys your soul...the depravity and the broken social contract.

Expand full comment
Hunterson7's avatar

The young Vietnamese child recovered and was moved to America, iirc. More than what Amelia received. We have been invaded and subdued, thanks to the deep state and its backers. Amelia was murdered because democrats hate America for not giving them more power

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you for this post, very important

Expand full comment
2nd Smartest Guy in the World's avatar

Prior to going after the imported savages we must go after those that imported them.

Mass arrests of all officials and Intelligence Industrial Complex players that allowed for this!

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

correct

Expand full comment
Robin Landry's avatar

Amen. Let Tom Holman do his job. He has my full backing to deal with these sub-humans any way he wants.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

Our greatest fears have now seemed to materialize. The school closures, social dislocation, the two years of isolation, the lockdown psychosis, plus dehumanizing masking and the resulting anxiety, depression, and despair, may have unleashed and may have enhanced depraved and murderous behavior.

Two major incidents have been in the news but the trend is larger. The FBI reports that deaths from active shooter incidents have soared. In 2021, the number of deaths reported as a result of active shootings (103 total) was a 171% increase from 2020. The relationship to lockdown policies should be apparent to any objective observer.

Socially malevolent behavior is potentially driven by the severing of the social contract, socialization, social bonds, and support normally operational in a functional society. The lockdowns and school closures shatter a sense of the future, of belonging, of ‘mattering,’ a sense of loss and hope and dreams of tomorrow that then can drive depravity and wickedness.

With pliable minds in young people, these prolonged restrictive policies facilitated tragic pathologies.

Consider the 18-year-old kid who shot up an elementary school in Uvalde, Texas, killing 19 young children, a teacher, and his own grandmother. Information is emerging by the hour, and we are still waiting on the motivations, but we already know the core problem: the gunman, filled with rage and hate, had been locked out of his school for a long period, denied essential social contact, support, and interaction that might otherwise have checked evil impulses.

With an open school and maskless students, with normal school days and no forced isolation, the teachers and administrators would have had a better chance at flagging him. In the midst of all the chaos and confusion, most people in his community came to believe that he had simply dropped out. The human being (potentially with or without already evil impulses) had become a monster who then revealed himself with massive carnage.

Similarly, a few weeks ago, a deranged 18-year old entered a TOPS grocery in Buffalo, New York and shot a reported 14 and killed 10 people. He was white and they, the dead, were black, though there are reports that two or three of those shot who survived (thus far), were white. He shot principally people based on their racial-ethnic makeup, being black. Raw, vicious hate.

Jeffrey Tucker of Brownstone Institute has perhaps done the most justice to these senseless acts and helped focus us onto a key implication of the failed COVID lockdowns. Tucker’s article focuses on the ravaging societal implications and how much the social isolation of the pandemic’s response can take a prior healthy mind and poison and destroy it, as it seemingly did with the Buffalo shooter, driving depths of racist depravity. A primitive, racist depravity that emerged after a sense of loss, social isolation, diminished and weakened hopes and dreams in the future, and the shattering of all that was normal and stable in a person’s life.

Before slaughtering people, the killer wrote:

“Before I begin I will say that I was not born racist nor grew up to be racist. I simply became racist after I learned the truth. I started browsing 4chan in May 2020 after extreme boredom, remember this was during the outbreak of covid…. I never even saw this information until I found these sites, since mostly I would get my news from the front page of Reddit. I didn’t care at the time, but as I learned more and more I realized how serious the situation was. Eventually I couldn’t take it anymore, I told myself that eventually I was going to kill myself to escape this fate. My race was doomed and there was nothing I could do about it.”

Tucker says that the Buffalo shooter conjured up a sense of belongingness via an “imagined artificial solidarity” with others of his clan with whom he had little if any contact; it was all in his deranged head.

Think of those who brought about these inhumane lockdown conditions. The laptop class operates so far removed from the consequences of their actions and disconnected from experiencing the ill effects of lockdowns directly, that they were willing to dispense with sacred rights and liberties of others. In so doing, they decimated societal rules, norms, moral codes, and social mores that took us several hundred years to fashion as part of good societies.

In addition, facial masks may have had a role in the actions of the depraved killers in both Buffalo and Uvalde. The constant mask wearing while in public may have broken the mind and severed the human connection, ending the silent but necessary communication that takes place between human beings.

So very much communication, emotion, care, tenderness, and non-verbal cues can be seen in each other’s faces. Unable to interact with others and unable to see faces when one does, we necessarily blunt compassion, connection, and empathy. It is entirely possible that young people were placed into sheer terror and loss as their entire social existence and connectedness were thereby shredded.

We now must mourn and grieve these tragedies and for the lost souls and their families. It is pain that defies any human discourse and it is now that we must turn to our gods and to each other for understanding, support, solace, and healing. It is our faiths and our communities that will get us through these senseless acts.

Is this Buffalo teen shooter and the Texas teen shooter the last such shooters? I fear not, as we may have damaged the minds of many people irreparably. There are grave consequences due to lockdowns and school closures, not only from a weakened immune system and the vast economic damage, but also due to the wrecked psyches of many young people.

Had the governments, policy makers, and covid Task Force officials heeded the early warnings on the disastrous lockdown and school closures, we may have been able to circumvent such tragedies. It is imperative now that we have urgent discussions that are broadened and include experts who bring alternative viewpoints to the table.

We may have opened Pandora’s box with these crushing school closures, forced masking, and lockdowns. The ramifications are beginning to emerge. Lockdown policies have damaged society, structurally and psychologically, and for a very long time to come. It might take the rest of the 21st century or longer for society to recover from the devastation of lockdown policies.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

I wrote this paper published

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

lockdowns, masks damaged us, COVID will have an effect for 100 years

Expand full comment
DUANE HAYES's avatar

I've found it astounding that almost every mass shooter left mountains of evidence before hand that they were a danger and likely to do something horrific, and yet the system, people knowledgeable about the danger, did nothing or even if they warned others, nothing was done. The FBI was warned in one case, and did nothing. I knew one such person, and the police wouldn't remove his guns, he eventually was taken in for observation, then set free where he ended up suicide by cop.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you for this sharing, this is truly horrendous, and your observation is key

Expand full comment
IslandGirl57's avatar

How does this affect those Muslim females who have to wear burkas?

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

ravaging societal implications and how much the social isolation of the pandemic’s response can take a prior healthy mind and poison and destroy it, as it seemingly did with the Buffalo shooter, driving depths of racist depravity. A primitive, racist depravity that emerged after a sense of loss, social isolation, diminished and weakened hopes and dreams in the future, and the shattering of all that was normal and stable in a person’s life.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

Think of those who brought about these inhumane lockdown conditions. The laptop class operates so far removed from the consequences of their actions and disconnected from experiencing the ill effects of lockdowns directly, that they were willing to dispense with sacred rights and liberties of others. In so doing, they decimated societal rules, norms, moral codes, and social mores that took us several hundred years to fashion as part of good societies.

Expand full comment
Jen Spencer's avatar

It was horrific to watch. The police did nothing and neither did ANY bystanders who just sat there and filmed. How would you feel if that was you or your loved one. At least, attempt to help her in whatever way you can. This video shows clearly how low we have sunken as a society and frankly it will only get worse. What is happening is disgusting! Criminals need to be treated very harshly!!

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

thank you for this and for her family to know people like you exist

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

nobody helped her

Expand full comment
Hannahlehigh's avatar

I was shocked to my core when I saw that video, and wtf, who was videoing her instead of helping her, the world has gotten desensitized to trauma thanks to cell phone cameras, they don't give a shit, they'd rather get likes and go viral. May God wrap His wings around this precious angel, RIP Amelia.

Expand full comment
Kathleen Taylor's avatar

I fear the videographer was dreaming of a huge payoff for selling the clip to the media rather than recognizing Amelia's humanity. An empty shell of a person without empathy.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Disgusting beyond words.

Expand full comment
KP Stoller's avatar

Many are blaming the Daniel Penny episode from keeping others from helping the poor burning gal out of the fear good Samaritans get prosecuted int NYC, but this is not an atypical event in NYC. Who remembers March 13, 1964, Kitty Genovese, a 28-year-old bartender, was raped and stabbed outside the apartment building where she lived. Despite her screams no one came to her aide.

Something is seriously fussed up in that city and has been fussed up obviously for decades. We are dealing with spiritual insanity and this is what brings down societies. Tic Tok, time is nigh.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

yes, I agree. spiritual insanity

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

you are right on the Kitty G rape, shocked us all...

Expand full comment
Sharon R. Fiore's avatar

Yes, that was the one I was referring to in another comment. People did that then and they are doing it now. We have been sick for a very long time. And the millennials and generation Z will not listen to us.

I tried to tell my cousin how scary it is for a woman who been molested to have a man come in her restroom, and all she could say was that people who are prejudice against these trans are just sick ignorant people. When I tried to tell her the statistics, she said I don’t wanna listen. I don’t wanna listen.

Expand full comment
Dr. Paul Alexander's avatar

We may disagree on many issues, even, yet I respect you greatly.

Expand full comment