16 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Rust's avatar

My thoughts: NO. Hell no. Let Jordan take them in. Or even better, maybe Saudi Arabia can step up. We have enough troublemakers of a certain religion in America already. Nicky Haley needs to STFU and STFD.

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

I agree. But the US should go further and offer part of the US to Israelis to create a new Jewish homeland. Before Israel was established in the middle-east there were plans to use part of north-western Australia to create a Jewish homeland. Create another Jewish homeland in the US. There need not only be one. Florida would be ideal. Disperse Floridians to other areas and resettle Israelis who want to relocate in Florida. Let those who want to remain in the middle-east remain.

Expand full comment
Kathleen Taylor's avatar

I suppose this is meant as provocation rather than a serious suggestion. A Jewish homeland in the US is as irrelevant (for lack of a better word) as the Australian plan. Jonathan Swift would smile.

Expand full comment
Eleftherios Gkioulekas's avatar

We do have a lot of land in the United States that are national parks, and we just pick one of the big ones and repurpose it for a second Jewish homeland. It is not an impossibility and could be done without displacing anyone. This is of course just a thought experiment and it taking it a step further, it is clear that it wouldn't stop the Hamas from coming in through our open borders and targetting that new homeland.

Expand full comment
Yal NA's avatar

For all idiots here: the jewish homeland is not just any old region for jews to settle. It has meaning such as if you heard if it Jerusalem. Yes jerusalem also has a bit of meaning to Christians.

Expand full comment
Esther Lindberg's avatar

The Torrah & Bible give the history of the Jews/Israel. Jerusalem is God's city where Yeshua will reign from during the millenium. Start from Creation in Genesis 1:1 & get to know God & Jesus Christ by Holy Spirit. He created us in His image to fellowship with! Shalom!

Expand full comment
Marjorie Miller's avatar

You mean Jesus wasn't born in Montana? That's not what I heard...

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

The ancestral homeland of most of the Jewish people is Europe, Yal NA. See the article at the first link. However, there is rising hostility toward them in Europe again today, on a backdrop of a very dark history in Europe. There is also great hostility toward them in the middle-east and there is no sign of that abating. Others whose ancestors have lived there a long time also claim Jerusalem and a not insignificant number are Christian. Australia or a part of it almost became Israel. See the articles at the l2nd, 3rd and 4th links. Carving out a piece of the US and giving it to the Jewish people makes sense. The Jewish people may not be indigenous to the US but neither are most Americans. Many of the US leaders, including Chuck Schumer, Jerry Nadler, Adam Schiff, Merrick Garland and many others are Jewish so there would be a cultural connection of the people of the New Israel to their new neighbors.

Surprise: Ashkenazi Jews Are Genetically European

https://www.livescience.com/40247-ashkenazi-jews-have-european-genes.html

How this part of Australia almost became Israel

https://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/how-this-part-of-australia-almost-became-israel/yg8nzanl3

How the Kimberley nearly became the Jewish homeland

https://www.australiangeographic.com.au/topics/history-culture/2018/09/how-the-kimberley-nearly-became-the-jewish-homeland/

Israel in the Kimberley: How the Top End nearly became a global Jewish hub

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-20/how-the-kimberley-almost-became-australias-israel/9566214

Expand full comment
Marjorie Miller's avatar

But my chiropractor is Jewish. Can't we just keep living in the same neighborhood?

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

Yes, sure, there's no need for forcible transfers of Jewish people. Where Jewish people choose to live should be entirely voluntary.

Expand full comment
BumbleBee's avatar

Unfortunately, the тАЬJewish HomelandтАЭ is a Zionist myth. The тАЬJewsтАЭ being тАЬre-homedтАЭ are an IndoArayan tribe originally from the Eurasian Steppe. They were mass converted on the orders of one of their kings in the 700тАЩs. They are the Ashkenazi Jews, and from them

weтАЩre born the Zionists with designs on taking Palestine since the late 1600тАЩs. The Orthodox Jews staunchly disagree with the Zionists and see them

as not true Jews. The Orthodox community disagrees with the founding of the State of Israel as their Torah says they shall not have, nor seek to establish, a homeland. They feel that their god will re-establish a homeland for them when he returns to earth. The Zionists are Ashkenazis including many of the most wealthy and powerful banking families in the world. They believe that they must lay waste to the earth, 2/3 of all Jewish people must die and the Temple of Solomon must be rebuilt to usher in the return of God and the rapture of the Zionist faithful to paradise. They seem to have been slowly fomenting this plan since they engineered the false flag sinking of the Lusitania to drag America into WWI to save Great BritainтАЩs bacon . The Zionists appear to have made a deal with the decil(so to speak), and theyтАЩll stop at absolutely nothing to bring about their vision. ItтАЩs the Zionists, the central banksters who fund them (many of whom ARE Zionists), and all their co-dependents and useful idiots whom we must stop!

Expand full comment
Esther Lindberg's avatar

Israel has /is fulfilling Biblical prophecies so accurately they cannot be denied if one studied by Spirit & Truth!

Expand full comment
AwakeNotWoke's avatar

With the US as the neighboring country, all the resources necessary for the survival of the new homeland would be close at hand. There would be cost savings for the US. It would no longer be necessary to deply US troops half way around the world to fight for it or defend it. Action could be taken quicker and Americans killed in defence of the new Jewish homeland would be close to the US and would not have to undertake a long journey home to be mourned and buried by loved ones.

Expand full comment
Marjorie Miller's avatar

Touchee!!! Well presented. A thought experiment for How would you feel? Indeed, unfortunately this has already been done, in Florida even, with the Indians and the Trail of Tears. Palestine was part of the Ottoman Empire, who lost WW1. Israel was an agreement with Britain that was on the winning side of WW1 and got to pick which parts of the Ottoman Empire that it wanted, as wars go. East and West Germany was a result of WW2. Wars have consequences and they usually aren't fair. The Ottoman Empire lasted 600 years and ruled the entire Middle East and no one even remembers them 100 years later. What we see today in the Middle East are the remaining pieces of the Ottoman Empire still fighting the outcome of WW1. Kinda like if the Indians attacked Florida today to get their land back and killed women, children and the elderly, scalping them, as opposed to slitting their throats, as custom would have it. What do U think would happen? Touchee back. ;)!

Expand full comment
Dee's avatar

I doubt people in Florida want to give up their homes to people from Israel. I don't know when the last time you were in Florida, but it feels multi-cultural to me already. Lots of people from different places there already.

Also I thought New York was home already to a lot of Jewish people.

Expand full comment